This is The Stepback, a weekly e-newsletter breaking down one important story from the tech world. For extra tales on Big Tech versus politics in Washington, DC, comply with Tina Nguyen and skim Regulator. The Stepback arrives in our subscribers’ inboxes at 8AM ET. Opt in for The Stepback right here.
A very long time in the past, in 2004, the Federal Communications Commission laid down a rule designed to stop a monopoly: No one firm might broadcast to greater than 39 p.c of all of the TV households within the United States. But then Donald Trump returned to the White House in 2025. Brendan Carr grew to become FCC chairman and instantly kicked off a deregulatory initiative known as “Delete, Delete, Delete,” through which Carr vowed to get rid of “every rule, regulation, or guidance document” that positioned “unnecessary regulatory burdens” on firms. And inside months, Nexstar, which already owned over 200 stations nationwide and had hit its possession cap, introduced that it had entered an settlement to buy its rival, Tegna, for an estimated $6.2 billion — one thing that would solely occur, nonetheless, if Carr agreed to vary the FCC’s guidelines.
If you ask Nexstar why it’s pursuing a merger that will give it management of over 80 p.c of the market, it’d level to Big Tech because the offender. As advertisers take their cash to Netflix, YouTube, and different digital streamers, linear tv — the local tv news, the published associates, the essential cable networks — has suffered, forcing them to consolidate and shut down newsrooms. In that sense, Nexstar argued, the merger would assist it compete for advert income with the streaming companies, thereby constructing extra strong local journalism. However, the merger’s opponents imagine that that is a fundamental violation of antitrust legal guidelines and rules — to not point out the hazard of letting one firm have editorial management over the overwhelming majority of America’s local tv newsrooms.
But the second Trump administration handles regulatory hurdles a little otherwise than others, and corporations have discovered that it’s sooner to get what they need in the event that they bypass the businesses and discuss (learn: suck up) to Trump instantly. And when Nexstar did so publicly, it confirmed its opponents’ fears about political affect. Last September, within the fraught weeks after the deadly taking pictures of Charlie Kirk, Nexstar introduced it might now not broadcast Jimmy Kimmel Live! — a response to Carr’s declare that the FCC might revoke the published licenses of TV stations that aired the comic’s feedback associated to Kirk. It briefly led to ABC suspending Kimmel’s present, although ABC and Nexstar quickly reversed their choice after a huge nationwide backlash and an ABC boycott.
However, Nexstar’s loyalty to Trump himself was not sufficient to win over his strongest MAGA supporters. Newsmax, a cable news community with a deeply pro-Trump bent, and its CEO, longtime Trump donor and out of doors adviser Chris Ruddy, filed a lawsuit objecting to the merger, claiming that Nexstar’s anticompetitive habits would drive channels like his off the air with steeper carriage charges. He particularly accused Nexstar of jacking up the charges for stations to hold Newsmax, whereas providing its related community, NewsNation, for less expensive.
The Nexstar-Tegna MAGA makeover then took a extra refined turn. NewsNation employed the pro-Trump Fox News commentator Katie Pavlich and gave her her personal primetime present. (The community had already employed a slew of former Fox journalists as effectively.) Around this time, a political group known as Keep News Local started airing advertisements in DC that appeared to instantly tackle Trump, praising him for having “defeated the fake news monopolies before through independent voices and local news” and claiming that the Nexstar-Tegna merger was “crucial for MAGA to survive.” (A bit of self-contradictory and mildly illogical, nevertheless it’s the type of stuff that Trump likes to listen to.) When I final spoke to Ruddy in February, I requested if he’d frightened that the darkish cash going into Keep News Local would sway Trump, and he selected his phrases fastidiously: “I think at the end of the day, Trump makes up his own mind. I’m not sure he’s going to be influenced by an ad campaign.”
For months, nobody might precisely predict if Trump would override Carr’s needs and bless the deal, as he’s usually accomplished for different firms going through regulatory scrutiny. Trump’s Truth Social posts in regards to the merger have been a good indicator of how precarious the merger has been and who’s been in a position to affect him at any given second: Last November, he blasted the deal as an “EXPANSION OF THE FAKE NEWS NETWORKS,” however by February, he posted that the deal would “help knock out the Fake News because there will be more competition.”
Several present and former NewsNation workers instructed Status on the time that they feared that the father or mother firm was steering NewsNation away from the centrist, “unbiased” popularity they’d lengthy cultivated. “A lot of people within the network believe that the network has gone hard right to appeal to Trump and Brendan Carr,” one former worker instructed Status. Coincidentally, days earlier than the deal was finalized, NewsNation started ramping up its explicitly pro-Trump content material, tweeting a clip of CNN’s Kaitlan Collins being berated by White House press secretary Karoline Leavitt, together with the remark “Just going to leave this here.”
When Trump greenlit the merger in mid-March, however earlier than the FCC’s three commissioners might vote on whether or not to waive the possession cap, Nexstar and Tegna instantly introduced a new complication: Tegna and Nexstar had already began merging. Tegna was no extra and CEO Mike Steib had already offered $22.6 million of his firm inventory.
In response, eight state attorneys common and satellite tv for pc TV operator DirectTV, which had already been planning to file separate federal antitrust fits towards the merger, requested US District Judge Troy Nunley in Sacramento for an emergency restraining order that will forestall Nexstar from taking on Tegna’s belongings. The order was granted on March twenty seventh and on April 17, Nunley issued a formal injunction, ruling that Tegna have to be operated as an unbiased monetary entity, and Nexstar should take steps to make sure it stays separate from Tegna earlier than additional authorized proceedings.
For now, Nunley has allowed the states and DirecTV to mix their circumstances, through which each argue that the merger was a clear violation of antitrust legal guidelines and would crush news competitors.
Meanwhile, Republicans and Democrats in Congress are livid at Carr. On March thirtieth, Sens. Ted Cruz (R-TX) and Maria Cantwell (D-WA) despatched the chairman a joint letter admonishing him for permitting his employees to waive the laws to let the merger move, as an alternative of having the complete fee of political appointees — one from the Biden administration — vote on it. “Under these circumstances,” they wrote, “any subsequent vote risks being largely procedural rather than a genuine exercise of commission responsibility.” They additionally identified that their hasty approval with out the fee’s approval would now complicate the merger financially: “In a transaction of this scale, where integration proceeds quickly and unwinding becomes impractical, delay in judicial review can insulate the decision from meaningful challenge.” Notably, although they share related ideological views on the media and deregulation, Cruz and Carr have steadily clashed over methods to obtain their targets. Cruz beforehand slammed Carr as a “mafioso,” as an example, for the best way he’d used the FCC to silence Kimmel.
But even when it’s legally paused, the journalistic merger’s fallout has began to hit local news. NPR’s David Folkenfirk reported on Tuesday that Tegna journalists had already began receiving orders to cease broadcasting content material from main broadcasters like ABC, CBS, and NBC — media shops being focused by Carr — and as an alternative start airing content material from Nexstar’s NewsNation.
- Brendan Carr’s views on utilizing the FCC to punish main broadcasters was outlined fairly extensively within the chapter he authored in Project 2025, an initiative led by the conservative Heritage Foundation on methods to reform the federal forms to be extra favorable to the American proper.
- Exactly how a lot is local tv dropping to digital? According to trade publication NewscastStudio, in an investor name defending the acquisition, Nexstar chairman Perry Sook cited a market analysis research from Borrell Associates, which discovered that “digital advertising in local markets exceeds $100 billion, compared to just $25 billion for local linear television advertising, with nearly two-thirds of digital ad dollars flowing to five major technology companies.”
- If you need to see precisely how a lot Keep Local News was making an attempt to suck as much as Trump, the advertisements are archived right here.
- The Vergecast has a long-running phase known as “Brendan Carr is a dummy.”
- The LA Times reported on final week’s preliminary hearings in entrance of Nunley, and the way legal professionals for Nexstar, the states, and DirecTV plan to argue their case.
- The Desk has insights from Kirk Varner, a former TV newsroom director, on how the case might go.
- Andrew Liptak coated Nexstar’s earlier acquisition sprees for The Verge in 2018.
- Adi Robertson walks by way of precisely how the Kimmel suspension was an assault on free speech.
- Brendan Carr retains making an attempt to persuade people who he’s not threatening to droop broadcast licenses for reporting on unfavorable issues just like the Iran conflict, reviews Lauren Feiner.
- The Vergecast has a long-running phase known as “Brendan Carr is a dummy.”