Home Headlines Karnataka alleges excess ethanol in petrol samples, drawing denials from oil marketing companies and Centre

Karnataka alleges excess ethanol in petrol samples, drawing denials from oil marketing companies and Centre

By Kaumi Gazette
Reader interest · ~2,860
Karnataka alleges excess ethanol in petrol samples, drawing denials from oil marketing companies and Centre

NEW DELHI: India’s national ethanol-blending programme has drawn fresh scrutiny after the Karnataka government alleged that retail petrol samples in the state contained ethanol levels significantly exceeding the prescribed 20% limit.

The controversy, which emerged after Karnataka announced test findings from seven districts, has triggered political friction between the Centre and opposition-ruled states. Following Karnataka’s allegations, the Kerala government ordered inspections at petrol pumps across four districts to test fuel samples. Public sector oil marketing companies (OMCs) and the Ministry of Petroleum and Natural Gas have rejected the claims, questioning the testing methodology while maintaining that fuel supplied nationwide conforms to Bureau of Indian Standards (BIS) specifications.

The dispute centres on tests conducted by Karnataka, the findings of which were announced on November 6 by the state’s food, civil supplies and consumer affairs minister Rizwan Arshad. According to the state government, samples collected from 63 outlets across seven districts showed ethanol concentrations exceeding the 20% limit, with several crossing 30% and nearly four out of five samples showing blending above the prescribed threshold.

After initial testing at Indian Oil and Bharat Petroleum laboratories did not provide reports on ethanol content, the state approached private laboratories accredited by the National Accreditation Board for Testing and Calibration Laboratories (NABL) and ISO-certified facilities. Karnataka alleged that motorists were paying for petrol while receiving fuel with higher ethanol proportions, raising concerns over vehicle performance and maintenance, and called for compensation for consumers and transparency in fuel disclosures.

State-owned oil companies (Indian Oil, Bharat Petroleum, and Hindustan Petroleum) dismissed the allegations in a joint statement, stating that inspections were conducted without their representatives and that they were not provided with retained samples, complete laboratory reports, or technical details. The OMCs questioned whether the certificates cited by Karnataka established compliance with BIS testing standards and requested complete documentation, outlet-wise reports, and access to counterpart samples for independent testing using prescribed referee methods.

The OMCs cited a joint quality-monitoring exercise with the Centre for High Technology, where 893 samples tested across 27 states and union territories (including 56 from Karnataka) met the prescribed 19% to 21% range, with Karnataka samples averaging 19.3% ethanol. The companies stated that blending at refineries and depots is undertaken through calibrated, automated systems under strict quality-control protocols rather than arbitrary manual addition.

The Ministry of Petroleum and Natural Gas backed the OMCs, stating that companies have no commercial rationale or incentive to blend beyond targets, as procurement costs for ethanol are significant and excess blending would increase operational expenses.

India achieved 20% ethanol blending in petrol last year, five years ahead of its original deadline, making E20 the standard retail blend. The rapid transition from 10% to 20% blending over three years has previously drawn criticism from motorists of older vehicles and two-wheelers designed for lower blends, who reported reduced mileage and engine wear. While opposition leaders have called for lower blends such as E10 or unblended petrol to be made available, the Centre and OMCs have maintained that E20 offers superior anti-knock characteristics and cleaner combustion. The government has also stated that offering multiple fuel grades would create major logistical challenges and increase retail network costs, though an August opinion piece co-authored by Chief Economic Adviser V Anantha Nageswaran had suggested making lower blends available alongside E20.

Published 17 November 2026 12:01 PM · India

Related stories

More from India